Finding Family

One woman's obsession with family history.

I suppose one thing that keeps family historians continually coming back for more is the chance that while researching you’ll come across a great find that truly knocks your socks off. These finds generally mean that a slow period in your research is suddenly and furiously propelled back into gear as you find yourself surrounded by new names and new avenues of discovery. This happened to me within the last few weeks.

Along with the wonderful people from RootsChat, I’ve been working on the New Zealand connection of the Nicholson side of the family tree for some time. Not being a resident of New Zealand, I posted my queries on the website and since then, they’ve been visiting libraries and looking up records on my behalf. It’s truly touching! As a break, I tore my attention away from the Nicholsons and started focusing on the McCarthys (my Great x 2 Grandfather, Edward Nicholson married Agnes Elizabeth McCarthy). I’m so glad I did!

I had the names of the parents of Agnes Elizabeth McCarthy and through also discovered many names of her siblings (some of whom died at a very young age). I took a chance, pulled out the credit card and ordered one of Agnes’s siblings’ birth certificates. From this certificate I discovered that Agnes’s parents (Patrick McCarthy and Elizabeth Kennedy) were both born in Tipperary, Ireland (1831 and 1833 respectively). They were also married in Tipperary in 1854. By 1856 however they were living in Victoria. Patrick’s occupation was a ‘miner’ and I can’t help but assume that perhaps the family left Ireland to escape the Irish Potato Famine in the hope of a better life and to possibly ‘strike it rich’ on the Victorian Goldfields.

At the moment, my details on Patrick and Elizabeth are still quite sketchy.

I also spent a great deal of time trolling through Trove in the hope of finding other clues on the McCarthy family. I changed my search terms and then happened to discover this Death Notice for John McCarthy:

Death Notice

Immediately the pieces fell into place. I already knew that Agnes had a sister (Mary Kate McCarthy) who married George Archer Cochrane and thanks to my Pop’s brother, I also knew that she was known to everyone as Polly. It was only logical then to assume that Aggie and Agnes (being incredibly similar) are one and the same person, my Great x 2 Grandmother and also John’s sister.

For some time I’d had the birth records of John McCarthy listed on my tree but before this article I never had any information on what became of him. I now knew that like his sisters he’d made the move to Western Australia.

The next stage consisted of adding the name of John’s spouse (Margaret Burke), adding their subsequent children (nine sons) and then filling in as many finer details as possible on the family tree.

The searching on Trove soon engulfed me and became my primary focus. I once again decided to switch up my search terms and tried ‘McCarthy Victoria Park’ (Victoria Park being where John and his family resided).

It was these words that brought forth that one great find.

WWI and WWII combined, seven of John McCarthy’s sons enlisted as soldiers. Such a remarkable number drew the attention of The Daily News and they printed a feature article on Wednesday, 24 December 1941.

Photo Article

I’m sure you can imagine just how excited I was when I opened the article and saw lined around the edge, eight photos from the one family! I was looking upon the face of my Great x 2 Grandmother’s brother and all her nephews. Considering the sparse photos on this side of the family, seeing these meant an awful lot.

The article in itself further provides information about John McCarthy, his occupation and how he got the nickname ‘Spiker’. Curiously, my Pop’s nickname was also Spike and it makes me wonder whether there’s a reason for why they’re so similar. John also describes his fright when he had a run in with Power from the Kelly Gang at age 12. The family lived in Victoria around the time of Ned Kelly and the Kelly Gang but I’d never considered this fact or the possible impact of it amongst the communities they lived in. Like many Australians today my thoughts of Ned Kelly are often positive and leaned towards him being a great iconic Australian folk hero.  I suppose they’ll always remain this way, but it’s interesting to read that John McCarthy in particular lived in fear and thinking about it now, I’m sure he wasn’t the only one.

My favourite quote by John however gives me a snippet of information of what growing up may have been like for my Great x 2 Grandmother:

Ours was a big family and we had to start work pretty early to help the home.

There’s no doubt the family was a large one. My records show Patrick and Elizabeth had eleven children. Of those children, I know of four that died quite young. The actual number of surviving children is currently unknown (I only know of four) but it is possible that the other three also survived – I just don’t have the records, yet.

From John’s words though, I take it that Patrick’s success on the goldfields may not have been what he was hoping for.

Despite making tons of progress, I’ve still got quite a bit more work to do on the McCarthys. I haven’t yet been able to find out what happened to both Patrick and Elizabeth and I definitely need to brush up on my knowledge of the goldfields, firstly, by reading David Hill’s book, The Gold Rush and then, any other book I can get my hands on.

Perhaps, in time, I’ll be able to write about Patrick and his family and his life on the goldfields but until then…

Happy searching!

Finding Family can now be found on Facebook!
Visit and click like!


  • 1942 ‘Family Notices.’, Sunday Times (Perth, WA : 1902 – 1954), 19 July, p. 2, viewed 6 July, 2012,
  • 1941 ‘SEVEN SOLDIER SONS.’, The Daily News (Perth, WA : 1882 – 1950), 24 December, p. 3 Edition: CITY FINAL, viewed 6 July, 2012,
  • Australia Birth Index, 1788-1922 [database on-line].
  • Australia Marriage Index, 1788-1950 [database on-line].

16 thoughts on “A Great Find

  1. ljhlaura says:

    Isn’t it lovely when the pieces fall into place and new doors open at the same time? Very exciting. And what a treasure you have in that news article … it’s lovely when suddenly discovered photographs introduce us to people about whom we’ve been wondering … The military service in that family is quite something.

    1. Jess says:

      It’s fantastic! My head’s been in family history mode for the last few weeks as I’ve worked to find out more info. I agree. The photos are definitely the best find especially seeing as though I dont even have photos of my own Great x 2 Grandmother. Thanks for reading and leaving a comment! 🙂

  2. geniaus says:

    Thanks to Thomas MacEntee of Geneabloggers I have found your blog – always excited to add another Australian blog to my RSS. Look forward to readin about your genealogy journey

    1. Jess says:

      That’s fantastic! I only just sent off a request to Geneabloggers. I haven’t seen many Australian genealogy blogs out there so I look forward to following your blog too. 🙂

      1. geniaus says:

        Jess, My main blog is – there is quite an active but small geneablogging community in Australia through which I have made some great online GeniMates.

  3. Neville Jones says:

    Another great story Jess and a research lesson – change search parameters! I spent hours researching WWI veteran husband of 2nd cousin 2 x removed Lucy Mary Solly includng in the Australian Light Horse Studies centre ( with a fair deal of success. Hours later, a slight tweak in Google search brought me back to the ALH Centre but this time to a direct link to the man’s personal WWI photo album that is lodged at the ALH Centre.


    1. Jess says:

      That’s also a great find Neville! I always try to think outside the box when using search engines, especially with Trove. One trick I use: I sometimes find that simply searching for an ancestor’s address or street and suburb brings forth a few “hidden” results. It seems in the past people had no qualms with sharing their personal details in the paper. Thanks for reading and leaving a comment. 🙂

  4. Fiona says:

    Lovely to find another Aussie blogger! What a great story and a fantastic find with the pics.

    1. Jess says:

      Thanks Fiona! I’m looking forward to checking out your blog too. 🙂

  5. Great story. I’m new to your blog and looking forward to reading through it and to your future posts:)

    1. Jess says:

      Thanks Michael! I hope you enjoy reading them as much as I enjoyed writing them. 🙂

  6. pitman6 says:

    Visiting from Geneabloggers. I love finding such newspaper articles! I’ve got Aussies in my family tree as well (I’m American). Mine are not ancestors but living close relatives that I don’t get to see often enough.

    1. Jess says:

      Hi pitman6,

      Thanks for stopping by and leaving a comment. I could spend hours searching through the old newspapers! The ads in particular and how they sold products back then fascinates me. 🙂

  7. Kerryn says:

    I’m a bit behind the eightball here. Welcome Jess, from another Aussie geneablogger. I’ve only just found your blog, I’m now subscribed and thoroughly enjoying reading it. I also lose myself in Trove and NZ papers past so I can relate to your excitement. I’m also extremely grateful to the NZers in rootschat, they are so so helpful. I look forward to reading more of your posts.

    1. Jess says:

      Thanks Kerryn! I’m glad you’re enjoying the posts. I look forward to reading your blog too. 🙂

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: